Threads vs.Twitter

August 2, 2023

Jayde Robertson

 A Battle of social media titans

What is the internet if it's not riddled with controversy, gossip, or a new verbal boxing match?
Other than being boring, it wouldn’t be much, would it? 

In the ever-evolving realm of social media, a new rivalry is brewing that has sent shockwaves through the digital landscape. It's the clash between Threads, Meta's bold new entry into the social media arena, and the long-standing powerhouse Twitter. Like a high-stakes poker game, these social media titans are going all-in to capture the attention and engagement of users worldwide. 

But who will emerge victorious in this battle for the hearts and minds of netizens?

Let's dive into the ring and witness the showdown unfold!

Threads: The slick newcomer in town

Step aside, Twitter. Threads has burst onto the scene, bringing its own brand of sleekness and sophistication. With a user-friendly setup process, all it takes is a quick download and linking to your Instagram account to gain access. 

Threads shares some similarities with Twitter, allowing users to craft short posts of up to 500 characters, complete with links, photos, and videos up to five minutes long. It's a seemingly perfect blend of Instagram's visual appeal and Twitter's brevity.

Or is it? 

The meteoric rise

Prepare to be astounded by Threads' meteoric rise in popularity. Why? Because it’s a shiny new distraction - by design, 

Within a remarkably short period, the app has attracted an astounding two million users, and the numbers continue to climb at an unprecedented pace. July 2023 was the month that we had a front-row seat to the latest social media supernova! 

But, we can’t forget the heavyweights in the ring. 

Twitter, with its impressive 230 million users, has been reigning supreme in the realm of short-form messaging for years. And then we have Instagram, flexing its biceps with a mind-boggling two billion users, taking the visual storytelling game to new heights. It's a battle of the Titans.

If even a fraction of those Instagrammers hops aboard the Threads bandwagon, it could catapult the app into the upper echelons of social media stardom. Obviously, Threads would have to get a lot right for that to happen, but the possibility seems almost… ominous. Is Zuckerberg really on a mission to monopolize social media? Who knows, but that’s a story for another day.

The mysterious newsfeed

Prepare to enter the labyrinthine world of Threads' newsfeed. 

Despite the public's eagerness for a serious Twitter alternative, the hasty launch and Meta's attempts to mold the concept may have dealt a severe blow to its success. In fact, it might even be on the verge of collapse. (Seriously, already?) 

Interest in Threads is dwindling rapidly, with daily active users plummeting by a staggering 20% within a matter of days. Even more telling is the significant drop in the amount of time users spend on the app. What was once a respectable 20-minute browsing session has been mercilessly slashed in half to a mere 10 minutes. 

The root of the problem (reportedly, I haven’t tried - you’ll find out why in the next section) lies in the app's main feed, which turned out to be a chaotic mishmash of content. While the idea of importing your Instagram followers seemed promising, the reality could have been better. Instead of seeing familiar faces and posts from people you genuinely cared about, your timeline became overrun by an onslaught of celebrities, brands, and influencers attempting to navigate this Twitter clone. It was as if they had taken a detour from their usual visually captivating content and found themselves trapped in a vortex of mind-numbing banality.

It's no wonder that users quickly grew disillusioned. Threads, which had the potential to be a true contender, quickly failed to deliver on its promises. The clash between the visual nature of Instagram and the text-based nature of Twitter proved to be a formidable challenge. The resulting mashup left users craving the simplicity and familiarity of the platforms they had grown accustomed to. #takemehome

But, as they do, the Threads algorithm slowly but surely unravels the mystery, eventually serving up familiar faces. 

As the dust settles and the initial hype wanes, the fate of this once-promising app hangs in the balance. Will it be able to recover from its missteps and capture the attention of disillusioned Twitter users? Or will it fade into obscurity, just another casualty in the fast-paced world of social media?

Don’t slide into my DM’s

In the game of social media, sliding into DMs has become an art form. However, Threads has decided to play hard to get in this department. If you're looking for a direct line of communication, you'll need to make a detour to the tried-and-true Instagram app. 

Threads may not be the one-stop-shop for all your messaging needs, but who said love and connection were meant to be easy? 

Sometimes, the thrill lies in the chase.

You can’t just leave

Once you step into Threads' realm, there's no turning back without bidding farewell to your beloved Instagram. It's a package deal that demands a significant sacrifice. Like a secret society with a no-exit policy, Threads keeps you locked into its ecosystem. (Cue the American Horror Story intro tune).  Departing means severing ties with your entire Instagram existence. It's a tough decision, akin to checking into a glamorous hotel with no checkout option.

The decision to embrace Threads and bid adieu to Instagram is not to be taken lightly. It's a choice that requires careful consideration of the pros and cons, weighing the benefits of a new social media adventure against the loss of a familiar online presence. For some, the allure of Threads may be irresistible. They are drawn to the novelty, the possibility of a fresh start, and the chance to be part of a growing community. They willingly accept the trade-off, ready to embrace the new and bid farewell to the old.

But for others, the decision is not so simple. The thought of severing ties with their Instagram identity, disconnecting from friends, memories, and a curated visual narrative, can be a daunting prospect. It's like closing the chapter on a beloved book, uncertain if the next one will be as captivating.

Threads presents a conundrum—a digital world that demands commitment and loyalty, where entering means embracing the unknown, and leaving comes at a cost. It challenges our desire for freedom and flexibility, forcing us to evaluate the value we place on our digital lives.

Yet, in this era of ever-evolving social media platforms, it's not uncommon for users to experiment, test the waters, and explore new digital territories. We are curious beings, constantly seeking novelty and fresh experiences. Threads offers a taste of something different, a chance to venture beyond the familiar confines of Twitter or Instagram.

Enter if you dare! Membership may be free, but the exit is pretty costly.

The battle rages on: What do we really think? 

The biggest selling point of this new platform might just be that it’s an opportunity to have a front-row seat to the latest tech-giant drama. That, and it’s not Twitter. 

Threads, Meta's answer to Twitter, has brought a fresh breeze of innovation to the social media landscape. With its sleek design, engaging features, and unique blend of Instagram and Twitter elements, it certainly has the potential to shake up the status quo. However, the battle for supremacy is far from over, and Twitter stands firm as the reigning champion of the social media realm.

The age-old adage holds true: you only get one chance to make a first impression. And unfortunately for Threads, that chance may have been squandered with its less-than-stellar launch. While it's true that the app is showing signs of improvement and making strides to rectify its initial missteps, the damage has already been done.

When Threads burst onto the scene, eager users flocked to give it a try, only to be met with frustration and disappointment. Glitches, design flaws, and a lackluster user experience tarnished what could have been a triumphant debut.

Now, to its credit, Threads is making strides to address the issues and improve its functionality. Updates and fixes are being rolled out at a rapid pace, and user feedback is being taken into account. It's evident that the team behind Threads is committed to turning things around and proving that they can deliver a top-notch product.

But the reality remains that those initial negative impressions linger in the minds of users. It's a tough battle to win back their trust and enthusiasm. People have short attention spans and countless alternatives at their fingertips. If an app fails to capture their interest from the get-go, they're quick to move on to the next shiny object in the digital realm.

So, while Threads may be improving quickly and striving to win back its users, the uphill battle it faces is undeniable. The lesson here is clear: launching an app prematurely, without thorough testing and refinement, can have long-lasting consequences. The importance of a strong first impression cannot be underestimated.

In the fiercely competitive landscape of social media, where new apps and platforms emerge with dizzying frequency, it's crucial to seize that initial opportunity to captivate and delight users. It's a delicate dance of innovation, user experience, and flawless execution.

As Zuckerberg and Musk lock horns in this digital showdown, we eagerly await the next chapter of this thrilling saga. Will Threads become the David that slays the Goliath of Twitter, or will Twitter's legacy endure? Only time will reveal the victor. So, fasten your seatbelts and stay tuned for the exhilarating twists and turns that await in the ever-evolving world of social media. 

Are you a marketer curious to learn about the aspects that affect our industry?

Or do you want to tap into our expertise to sharpen your tactics? Look no further than our free downloadable resources. We work hard to research our content - and offer it to you - free of charge.